Ban-the-Box Laws: What Employers Need to Know

Ban-the-box laws are reshaping how employers approach background checks and hiring. Designed to promote fair chances for individuals with criminal records, these laws restrict when and how an employer can inquire about a candidate’s criminal history during the hiring process. As more states and municipalities adopt ban-the-box policies, it’s essential for employers to stay informed and adjust their screening practices accordingly.

At Confirmify, we help companies remain compliant with all applicable screening regulations — including ban-the-box requirements — while continuing to make informed, risk-aware hiring decisions.

What Are Ban-the-Box Laws?

Ban-the-box laws prohibit employers from asking about an applicant’s criminal history on initial job applications. The “box” refers to the checkbox commonly seen on job forms asking whether a candidate has ever been convicted of a crime.

These laws don’t prevent employers from conducting criminal background checks entirely — they simply delay the timing of when such questions or checks can be introduced in the hiring process. The goal is to allow candidates to be evaluated on their skills and qualifications before any potential disqualification based on past offenses.

Who Do These Laws Apply To?

Ban-the-box laws vary widely by state, city, and industry. Some apply only to public employers (government jobs), while others include private-sector employers as well.

Common coverage includes:

Public agencies and contractors
Private employers over a certain size (e.g., 5+ or 15+ employees)
Positions not legally excluded from background check requirements

Employers must research the specific regulations in each location where they hire, as local laws may be stricter than federal rules. For multi-state employers, Confirmify’s compliance tools help you apply the right screening practices based on location.

When Can You Inquire About Criminal History?

Under ban-the-box laws, criminal history inquiries are typically allowed after a conditional offer of employment has been made. This ensures that candidates have an opportunity to present their qualifications before being screened for criminal background.

Here’s a general timeline under ban-the-box regulations:

Application Stage – No criminal history questions allowed.
Initial Interviews – Still no inquiry in many jurisdictions.
Post-Conditional Offer – Employers may conduct a background check and consider criminal history.
Adverse Action Consideration – If the results affect the hiring decision, employers must follow the FCRA process (pre-adverse and adverse action notices).

Some laws also require an individualized assessment, which means evaluating the nature of the offense, its relevance to the job, and how much time has passed since the conviction.

Best Practices for Ban-the-Box Compliance

To ensure compliance and fairness while protecting your organization, consider these best practices:

Remove the conviction checkbox from all job applications in applicable jurisdictions.
Train hiring teams on when and how background checks can be conducted.
Delay criminal background screening until after a conditional offer has been made.
Use individualized assessments to evaluate criminal history in context, rather than blanket disqualifiers.
Maintain clear documentation of all screening decisions and follow the adverse action process if needed.
Stay current with changing laws, as new jurisdictions continue to adopt and expand ban-the-box protections.

Confirmify’s platform is built with location-aware compliance features, helping you apply the right rules at the right time — automatically.

Why Choose Confirmify?

Confirmify helps businesses navigate ban-the-box laws with confidence by delivering background check solutions that are fast, accurate, and legally compliant. Our system ensures that criminal checks are timed appropriately, and that hiring decisions follow all FCRA and local regulations. With average turnaround times of 8 hours to 3 days — and clients reporting 30–50% faster results compared to their previous providers — we make compliance simple without slowing down your hiring process. Whether you hire locally or across multiple states, Confirmify helps you stay fair, fast, and fully compliant.

READY TO PLACE AN ORDER?

CALL AND CHAT WITH AN ACCOUNT SPECIALIST